Collagen supplements and powders have taken the wellness world by storm, promising a fountain of youth and a multitude of health benefits. From glowing skin to stronger joints, the potential advantages seem endless. But with a dizzying array of brands and formulations on the market, navigating the collagen landscape can feel overwhelming.
In this blog post I try to equip you with the knowledge to choose the best collagen supplement to address your unique needs. We’ll look the different types of collagen, explore the various sources, and decipher the science behind additional ingredients. By the end of this journey, you’ll be empowered to make informed decisions and unlock the potential benefits of collagen for yourself.
In which cases collagen supplementation may be helpful?
While collagen supplements have become increasingly popular, they aren’t necessarily for everyone.
Who may benefit:
- Those with a diet lacking collagen: If you don’t consume many collagen-rich foods like bone broth or fish, supplements may help bridge the gap.
- People with signs of aging skin: Collagen production naturally declines with age, potentially leading to wrinkles and loss of skin elasticity. Collagen supplements may help improve skin hydration and plumpness.
- Those experiencing joint pain: Some research suggests collagen peptides may help reduce pain associated with osteoarthritis.
- Athletes and people with active lifestyles: Collagen is a major component of connective tissues, and supplementation might aid in recovery from exercise-related injuries.
- Individuals with gut issues: Collagen may play a role in gut health, and some studies suggest it could help improve gut lining integrity.
Do collagen supplements work?
Scientific studies suggest that collagen supplementation may promote increased skin elasticity, hydration, and overall firmness. A study published in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology (1) found that participants who took collagen supplements experienced a significant reduction in wrinkle depth and improved skin hydration. Another study in the Journal of Medical Nutrition and Nutraceuticals (2) demonstrated the positive impact of collagen peptides on skin elasticity and moisture content. These findings support the notion that collagen supplementation can be a valuable addition to one’s skincare routine, helping to combat signs of aging and enhance skin vitality.
However, it’s essential to choose high-quality products. And still, more research is needed to fully understand the effects and dosages for various purposes as there’s a lack of randomized controlled trials.
COLLAGEN PEPTIDES VS COLLAGEN - WHICH FORM IS MOST EFFECTIVE?
Collagen and collagen peptides are related, but with a key difference: bioavailability, or how easily your body can absorb them. Collagen peptides are likely better absorbed than regular collagen.
Collagen – whole collagen molecules are quite large and difficult for the body to digest and absorb directly from food or supplements.
Collagen peptides – also called as hydrolyzed collagen, are smaller bits of collagen created by breaking down whole collagen molecules through a process called hydrolysis. This makes them much easier for your body to absorb.
So now we know that rather look for collagen supplement/powder where collagen is in a form of peptides.
What is the difference between type I, II and III collagen?
There are 16 types of collagen, but supplements typically focus on types 1, 2, and 3. Type 1 supports skin health, type 2 benefits joints, and type 3 aids muscles and blood vessels. Identify your primary concern to pick the most relevant type(s).
-
Type I Collagen: This is the most abundant type, making up around 90% of your body’s collagen. Think of it as the building block for your skin, tendons, ligaments, bones, and even your teeth. It’s what gives your skin its plumpness and elasticity, and as you age, production of type I collagen naturally declines.
-
Type II Collagen: This type is the main component of elastic cartilage, which cushions your joints. Found in your spinal discs and eyes, it’s crucial for joint health and mobility. Unlike type I which is more widespread, type II collagen is concentrated in specific areas.
-
Type III Collagen: This type works alongside type I collagen, providing support to your skin, muscles, blood vessels, and intestines. It also plays a role in wound healing. While both types I and III contribute to skin health, some studies suggest type III might have a greater impact on reducing wrinkles and fine lines.
So consider what do you want to target with the collagen supplement: is it your skin, joints or something else, and choose the right supplement or powder that contains the type of collagen you need.
Collagen powder vs capsules - which one is better?
There’s no definitive answer to whether powder collagen or capsules are inherently “better.” Both have advantages and disadvantages, so the best choice depends on your preferences:
Powder Collagen:
Pros:
- Versatility: You can add it to various drinks (coffee, smoothies) or even food (yogurt, oatmeal).
- Potentially Lower Cost: Powders can sometimes be more affordable per serving compared to capsules.
- Easier to Adjust Dosage: You can easily measure out the exact amount of powder you need.
Cons:
- Mixing Required: You need to mix the powder with a liquid, which might be inconvenient for some.
- Taste: Some collagen powders may have a taste or odor you don’t enjoy.
- Messy: Scooping and measuring powder can be messy.
Capsule Collagen:
Pros:
- Convenience: Capsules are easy to swallow with water, perfect for people on the go.
- Tasteless & Odorless: Capsules eliminate any taste or odor concerns.
- Pre-Measured Doses: No need to measure; each capsule contains a specific amount of collagen.
Cons:
- Less Versatile: Limited to taking them with water.
- Potentially Higher Cost: Capsules might be slightly more expensive per serving compared to powder.
- Swallowing Difficulty: Some people might have trouble swallowing capsules.
Here’s a quick decision-making tip:
- Choose powder if: You enjoy customizing your drinks or prefer a potentially lower cost and adjustable dosage.
- Choose capsules if: You prioritize convenience, tastelessness, and pre-measured doses.
What is the best source of collagen?
There isn’t a single “best” source of collagen, as each has its advantages and disadvantages. Let´s see the different types.
Bovine Collagen (cow):
- Pros: Most abundant source, contains types I, II, and III collagen, may be cost-effective.
- Cons: Not suitable for vegans or those with allergies to beef. Absorption rate might be lower compared to marine collagen.
Marine Collagen (fish):
- Pros: May have higher absorption rate due to smaller molecule size, often sourced sustainably, good option for those with allergies to beef.
- Cons: Typically only contains type I collagen, might be more expensive than bovine collagen. People with fish allergies should avoid it.
Other Sources (pig, chicken):
- Less Common: Less prevalent in the market compared to bovine and marine sources.
- Considerations: Research these options for benefits and potential drawbacks specific to the source. Ensure they align with your dietary preferences and allergy concerns.
The best source depends on your individual needs and preferences. Consider these factors:
- Dietary Restrictions: if you’re vegan or have a beef allergy, marine collagen would be a better choice.
- Focus of Benefits: if you prioritize joint health, look for supplements containing type II collagen, which is more prevalent in bovine sources.
- Budget: bovine collagen might be a more cost-effective option.
- Sustainability: if that’s a concern, choose brands that prioritize responsible sourcing practices, especially for marine collagen.
Consulting a healthcare professional can also be helpful, especially if you have any underlying health conditions or are taking medications.
What about collagen supplements with additional ingredients like vitamin C? Are these better?
The answer is: it depends. Here’s what to consider:
- Do you need the additional benefits? About vitamin C as additional ingredient – if you’re already getting enough vitamin C through diet or other supplements and for example consume vitamin C rich food together with collagen, then a collagen supplement without it might be enouch. Same applies for other additional ingredients in collagen products. Usually less is more.
- How do you plan to consume your collagen supplements? Do you plan to consume collagen powder in your coffee, smoothie or some other way? For example, if you consume it with coffee then vitamin C in your collagen product might be beneficial.
- Are there any ingredients you dislike or can’t tolerate? Carefully read the label to avoid potential allergens or unnecessary ingredients.
- What’s your budget? Collagen with additional ingredients might cost more.
In conclusion, navigating the world of collagen supplements can feel overwhelming. But by considering the factors discussed above – collagen type, source, form, additional ingredients and quality – you can make an informed decision. Remember, there’s no single “best” collagen supplement, but the right one for you will target your specific needs and preferences. Be patient, consistent, and consult a healthcare professional if needed. With the right approach, you can embark on your collagen journey with confidence and potentially experience the health benefits it has to offer.
In the mean time you can have a look on my small research about some the best collagen supplements in the market and which one I chose myself here.